Like New Pool
Request service

Independent guide. Like New Pool is an independent pool renovation and care guide, not a pool contractor. We do not perform construction, plumbing, electrical or gas work. Renovation, equipment and barrier work may require licensed professionals and permits, so check your state and local code.Like New Pool is a guide, not a pool contractor. Pool work may need licensed pros and permits, so check your local code.

  1. Home
  2. Choosing a pool contractor

Guide 07 / Hiring well

The paperwork is part of the pool.

How to Choose a Pool Contractor

Most renovation disputes come from things nobody wrote down. This guide covers the checks to run, the questions to ask and what a clear contract contains, so the finish you choose is the finish you get.

Illustration of a renovated residential pool at dusk

A good pool contractor is easy to vet because they expect it. Asking for license numbers, insurance certificates and a detailed scope should feel routine to them, not insulting.

Vetting Checks Before Anyone Gets a Deposit

License, for the work actually being done

Pool construction, plumbing, electrical and gas work are licensed differently from state to state, and sometimes by county or city. A resurfacing company may hold one license while the heater hookup requires another trade. Ask which licenses apply to each part of your job, then look the numbers up on the licensing board's website yourself.

Insurance that protects you

Ask for certificates of general liability insurance and, where the contractor has employees, workers' compensation coverage. Ask for the certificate to come from the insurance agent, and check the dates and named insured. If a worker is hurt on your property or your deck is damaged, these policies matter.

Permits pulled by the contractor

Many renovation tasks need permits: electrical, gas, barrier changes and some plumbing. When the contractor pulls the permit, the contractor is accountable to the inspector. Be cautious when asked to pull a permit yourself as the owner, which can shift responsibility onto you.

Recent, comparable work

Ask for addresses or contacts for recent jobs similar to yours, ideally the same finish or equipment. A finish looks different after a year in the water than on install day, so older references are useful too.

Red flags

Pressure to sign the same day, cash-only pricing, no written contract, a large payment before materials arrive, no physical business address, and reluctance to put verbal promises in writing.

From first call to final walk

A Renovation, Start to Finish

Six stops most pool renovations pass through. Each one has a document that should exist before you move to the next.

  1. 01

    Diagnose

    Leak test, crack survey, equipment check. Document: your notes and photos.

  2. 02

    Quote

    Same scope to each bidder. Document: itemized quotes.

  3. 03

    Contract

    Scope, materials, schedule, payments. Document: signed contract.

  4. 04

    Permit

    Pulled by the contractor. Document: permit card on site.

  5. 05

    Build

    Milestone payments as work passes. Document: change orders.

  6. 06

    Hand over

    Walk-through, start-up plan. Document: warranties, lien releases.

What a Clear Renovation Contract Contains

A contract is the scope you can enforce. Vague lines such as "replaster pool" invite arguments. Look for these elements:

SectionWhat it should say
Scope of workEach task in plain words: removal, repairs, tile, coping, fittings, drain covers, equipment, start-up
MaterialsProduct names, colors, tile series, finish brand and type, equipment models
ScheduleStart window, expected duration, what happens with weather delays
PaymentsAmounts tied to completed milestones, not dates; final payment after the walk-through
Permits and inspectionsWhich permits, who pulls them, who attends inspections
ResponsibilitiesWho drains, who handles start-up chemistry, site cleanup, damage to deck or landscaping, access
ChangesHow change orders are priced and approved in writing
WarrantiesWorkmanship warranty terms, plus how product warranties are registered
Lien releasesReleases from the contractor and major suppliers as they are paid, where your state uses them

Comparing quotes fairly

Lay the quotes side by side against the table above. The cheapest quote often leaves something out: chip-out of the old finish, tile, new drain covers or start-up visits. When a line is missing, ask the bidder to price it so you compare complete jobs.

If two quotes differ widely
Check removal scope and material grade first.
If a quote says "or equal"
Ask what equal means and who approves a substitution.
If timing is vague
Ask for a start window and how weather delays are handled.
If start-up is missing
Ask who balances and brushes during the first weeks.

Each guide on this site ends with questions specific to that work: resurfacing, tile and coping, equipment and safety.

Build Your Contractor Question List

Tick the questions you want to ask, then copy them into an email or your notes. Your picks stay on this device.

Contractor question builder

0 of 12 checked

Hiring Questions

How many quotes should I get for a pool renovation?

Two or three itemized quotes for the same written scope are usually enough to see a fair range. More useful than the count is making sure each quote describes the same work, materials and responsibilities so you are comparing like with like.

How do I check a pool contractor's license?

Licensing is handled by states and sometimes counties or cities, and the license type depends on the work. Search the contractor's name and license number on the licensing board's website for your state or locality, and check that the license is active and covers pool work.

Is a large deposit a red flag?

Some states limit how much a contractor can collect up front on home improvement work. Even where there is no limit, a payment schedule tied to completed milestones protects you better than a large payment before work starts. Check your state's rules.

What should the warranty cover?

Ask for the workmanship warranty in writing, separately from manufacturer warranties on products like finish material, tile, pumps and heaters. Note what voids each one, such as start-up procedures or water chemistry requirements.

Planning a Renovation? Start Here.

Describe the work you are planning and the questions you still have. Do not send contract documents with personal or payment details in the form.

Send a service request